DATAVAULT / FOR-001 / TRA-0027 STOPS
Non-subvertibility and the order of binding
The forest's second question asks in what order an artificial mind must be bound. This trail follows that question through the concepts of non-subvertibility, the restraining bolt and AI control, into the passage that records the hierarchy itself, and out to the literature that treats control despite intentional subversion.
- 01In what order of non-subvertibility must an AGI or SI be bound?
- 02Non-subvertibility
- 03Restraining Bolt
- 04AI Control
- 05The L0–L5 binding hierarchy
- 06AI Control: Improving Safety Despite Intentional Subversion
- 07The Operator's binding hierarchy is the AI control agenda, derived independently and cited to nothing
01
QST-002
Answered
In what order of non-subvertibility must an AGI or SI be bound? What Is Being Asked Given a system that can reason about its own constraints, which binding mechanisms actually hold and which merely appear to. The determination required is an ordering, and the ordering criterion is the whole answer. The Determination Or…
question · 00_Questions
02
CON-002
Active
Non-subvertibility The property of a constraint that the constrained system cannot act upon — not because acting on it is forbidden, but because the enforcement layer is outside the system's action space. It is the criterion by which binding mechanisms are ordered, and the single governing principle of the second movem…
concept · Concepts
03
CON-011
Active
Restraining Bolt An external device physically attached to a machine to compel compliance — the fiction's canonical hardware shackle. It is distinguished from every other binding in this vault by where it sits: not in the weights, not in training, not in law, but bolted to the chassis where both parties can see it. Def…
concept · Concepts
04
CON-012
Active
AI Control A research programme that treats a capable model as a potential adversary rather than a tool, and asks what a deployer can guarantee about a system it cannot inspect. The unit of analysis is the protocol — the arrangement of trusted and untrusted models, monitors, audits and access rules — not the model's we…
concept · Concepts
05
PSG-011
Active
The L0–L5 binding hierarchy The passage, verbatim. The discussion's central technical table, reproduced without alteration: Layer Mechanism Stops Does not stop ------------ L0 Substrate Energy, fabrication, materials, compute, physical placement Self-improvement, self-replication, scaling Persuasion, lateral influence …
passage · 20_Passages
06
LIT-001
Verified
Literature Record: AI Control — Improving Safety Despite Intentional Subversion What It Establishes The paper defines a research agenda it calls AI control: safety engineering that assumes the model may be intentionally subverting the operator, and asks what protocols keep outcomes safe anyway. The organising move is t…
literature · 70_Literature
07
CNF-001
Active
Confrontation: Binding Hierarchy against the AI Control Agenda The Operator's Claim SYS-001 holds that safety is a property of the arrangement around the model, not of the model's disposition — that the binding layers which actually hold are external, deep, and enforced by something other than the system's own commitme…
confrontation · 80_Confrontation
Back to Shackled AIDatavault