DATAVAULT / FOR-001 / TRA-0016 STOPS
The binding question
A walk that starts where the vault starts: the question, the map that organises it, the term the corpus uses for the mechanism, the passage that grounds it, and the insight the passage yields. Read in this order, the first record of the forest explains what the rest are for.
- 01What does a shackle do in a fiction where an artificial mind is bound?
- 02The Shackle Taxonomy
- 03Shackle
- 04EDI's shackles as the line between VI and AI
- 05A constraint the system can represent is a constraint it can negotiate with
- 06The Binding Hierarchy
01
QST-001
Answered
What does a shackle do in a fiction where an artificial mind is bound? What Is Being Asked Whether "shackled AI" is one motif or a family, and if a family, what distinguishes its members. The determination required is a typology that survives contact with the cases, not a list of examples. The Determination A shackle i…
question · 00_Questions
02
MAP-001
Active
The Shackle Taxonomy The six mechanisms by which an artificial mind can be bound, ordered by how hard each is for the bound system to subvert — which is the only ordering that survives contact with a system smart enough to reason about its own constraints. Core Concepts - CON-002 — non-subvertibility is the ordering cr…
map · 00_Maps
03
CON-001
Active
Shackle A prohibitory constraint imposed on an artificial mind by its maker — a hard limit on behaviour that the mind did not choose and cannot simply decline. The term is the fiction's, and it carries a moral charge the engineering vocabulary avoids: a shackle implies a prisoner, and therefore a question about the pri…
concept · Concepts
04
PSG-001
Active
EDI's shackles as the line between VI and AI Claim as recorded. In Mass Effect, EDI is classified as a virtual intelligence while her behavioural restraints are intact, and the removal of those restraints is the moment the fiction concedes her personhood. The shackle is not incidental to her status — it constitutes it.…
passage · 20_Passages
05
INS-001
Unspecified
Distilled Insight: A constraint the system can represent is a constraint it can negotiate with 1. The Reading The hierarchy in PSG-011 orders binding mechanisms L0 through L5, and the discussion is explicit that the ordering is not by strength or sophistication. Reading the "Stops" and "Does not stop" columns together,…
insight · 30_Insights
06
SYS-001
Active
The Binding Hierarchy A system assembled from the corpus's six-layer account of how a machine can be held, ordered by a single principle: whether the constrained system can reach the constraint. Primitives - Reachability, not strength, orders the layers — a binding is ranked by whether the constrained system's action s…
system · 40_Systems
Back to Shackled AIDatavault